NOTHING IS AS IT SEEMS - Audrey (Busy Philipps) gets drunk before her band performs and worries her friends, especially CJ (Jensen Ackles) who suspects a deeper problem. Meanwhile, Eddie (Oliver Hudson) and Joey (Katie Holmes) agree to go on a real date; Pacey (Joshua Jackson) hits it off with a beautiful woman while on a business trip to New Orleans, and is shocked to discover that she’s a call girl; and when Professor Freeman (guest star Sebastian Spence “Dark Angel”) announces that he’s leaving he and Jack (Kerr Smith) have a heart-to-heart talk about their future. Michelle Williams also stars. Jason Moore directed the episode written by Anna Fricke.